Intermodulation distortion
Also called IMD, intermodulation
Intermodulation distortion (IMD) is the extra tones a device adds when two or more frequencies pass through it together, at their sums and differences. These tones bear no musical relation to the notes, so IMD can sound worse than harmonic distortion of the same size.
Feed an amplifier 1,000 Hz and 1,100 Hz together and a perfectly linear one outputs only those two. A real one adds faint tones at 100 Hz and 2,100 Hz, the difference and the sum, and at 900 Hz and 1,200 Hz from the next order. Music is many tones at once, so it produces a dense set of such products, and they land where no instrument put anything: below the notes and between them.
The same nonlinearity causes both IMD and harmonic distortion, so a device with low THD nearly always has low IMD too. The tests still see different things. A single-tone THD+N or SINAD measurement cannot count the harmonics of a treble tone, because they fall above 20 kHz and outside the window. An intermodulation test can, because the difference between two high tones lands back in the audible band.
In competent electronics IMD is very low. It matters more in loudspeakers, where a woofer making large bass excursions modulates the higher notes it is reproducing at the same time, one reason designers use a crossover to split the range between drivers. A related argument concerns hi-res files: ultrasonic content no one can hear may, in a tweeter or amplifier that is not linear far above 20 kHz, produce intermodulation products inside the audible range.
Common questions
What does intermodulation distortion sound like?
In small amounts, nothing. In larger amounts it sounds like roughness or congestion that grows with the number of instruments playing: a solo voice stays clean while a full orchestra or a dense rock mix turns harsh or muddy, because every pair of tones interacts. Since the products fall below and between the notes, IMD sounds more like grit than the added fullness some listeners hear in low-order harmonic distortion.
How is intermodulation distortion measured?
Two tones go in and an analyzer looks for new ones in the output. The SMPTE test uses 60 Hz and 7 kHz at a 4:1 level ratio and measures the sidebands that appear around 7 kHz. The CCIF or twin-tone test uses 19 and 20 kHz at equal level and measures the 1 kHz difference product and its neighbors. Results are given as a percentage, or in decibels below the test tones.
What is transient intermodulation distortion?
Transient intermodulation distortion, or TIM, is a form described in the 1970s: an amplifier with heavy negative feedback and a slow input stage briefly overloads on fast transients, before the feedback can correct it. It drew a long debate at the time. Modern amplifier designs usually have ample speed and bandwidth for any real music signal, so TIM is rarely raised as a practical concern today.
How do you reduce intermodulation distortion?
In a hi-fi system, mostly by keeping every part within its limits. Do not drive an amplifier into clipping, where all distortion rises steeply. Let a subwoofer take the deep bass so small woofers make smaller excursions, which reduces the speaker IMD that bass causes. In software, leave enough headroom that an equalizer boost does not clip. The electronics themselves rarely need attention.