Pros
- Very affordable
- Comfortable fit with the cloth covers on
- Midrange comes alive at high volumes
- Treble has decent sparkle and sheen
- Good sense of staging
Cons
- Underwhelming at low volumes
- Light mid-bass impact
- Neutral tonality comes off too sterile
- Sounds murky with the cloth covers installed
Very comfortable and cheap, but plain-sounding and thin until you turn it up.
TL;DR
The Traceless is the most comfortable earbud I have worn, but its cloth covers make the sound murky. It is acceptable at low and moderate levels and only really opens up when driven louder.
Without a decent source such as a DAC dongle it sounds generic and dull, and straight from a phone it would disappoint. Nothing about it separates it from other earbuds.
The tonality leans neutral rather than musical, which let me down, though how much that matters depends on your ears.
As a low-cost way to sample earbuds and learn to appreciate better fidelity, it is a reasonable first step.
Specs
Driver: 15.4mm PET dynamic driver
Frequency response: 20-20,000Hz
Impedance: 32Ω
Sensitivity: 115dB/mW
Plug: 3.5mm or Type C (optional)
Cable length: 1.2m ±5cm
What's in the box
NiceHCK Traceless earphones
3 pairs of cloth covers
First Impressions
Packaging is plain. A cardboard carton with a picture of the earbuds on the front holds the pair, sealed in a plastic tray along with three sets of cloth covers.
The range of colours is wide, including black, white, cyan, blue and pink, and you can pick a version with or without an inline microphone. My pair is purple. I have always had a soft spot for saturated colours, yet most flatheads seem to follow the same recipe of smoky translucent shells. NiceHCK went with high-gloss shells instead, and to my eye the difference is dramatic.
The cloth covers are another highlight. They are well made and give me the comfiest flathead wearing experience in quite some time. The catch is that they dull midrange clarity, so for the sake of the sound I ended up listening without them.
Even with the covers fitted, the sound is acceptable. I just prefer my mids as clean as possible. Overall, nothing here grabbed me, and I came away underwhelmed. Pushing the volume up makes the midrange far more capable, but beyond that I heard no meaningful change. They are fine, and fine is not enough when there are stronger alternatives around.
Build Quality
Construction is in line with other flatheads, with that generic OEM feel. The glossy housing, rather than the usual smoked plastic, gives a smoother finish and a welcome bit of individuality.
I only wish the cable had been as attractive as the shells. It is a weaker affair than the silver-plated or braided copper cables I normally see on budget sets.
All told, the build is nothing special but also nothing to grumble about at this price.
Fit and Comfort
For a flathead, these sit very comfortably in the ear. I had assumed flatheads simply could not avoid causing fatigue, and these have made me question that.
The covers look like the ordinary ones that ship with many earphones, but they feel noticeably better than the usual stock material. Without them, the bare shells get tiring over time. I wear mine uncovered purely because of the sound, so any discomfort I feel is my own doing.
Isolation is average, and with the covers fitted no sound escapes to bystanders.
Sound Quality
The tonal balance is, as best I can put it, as analogue as it gets: room temperature, tilting slightly toward lean.
My first reaction was confusion. A more neutral voicing is fine, but I wanted something in return for giving up warmth.
I figured a lean tuning would push detail and a straight, linear presentation to the front. Instead the mids come across as faint and thin rather than analytical. To get them to a satisfying level I needed roughly 70% volume on my DAP, and about 40% from a dongle plugged into my laptop.
The upside is that once you feed them more level the mids bloom nicely, and the overall tonality suits that.
Newer styles of music sound good, though the presentation is a bit flat, and the weak point is the supporting technical ability, which never adds much excitement. On "Orb" by Ichika Nito, even 70% volume left the electric guitar short on dynamic life, which let me down.
It is odd that metal works well while new age falls flat. "Unfamiliar" from Currents sounds great, with the weight and character of the guitars well conveyed. The straight, linear voicing is not a problem, since it simply passes along whatever you play.
On the other hand, some tracks can come across as dull. The tuning has highs and lows, but I think the mids and treble are handled well, and the technical performance sits just a notch below where I would like it, although not by much.
Bass
As with most flatheads, true sub-bass is simply missing. The mid-bass is lightweight, lacking kick and slam, and tracks that need a bit more thump suffer for it.
There is little more to add. The mid-bass is a letdown, the weakest part of the Traceless, and likely a big reason the whole tuning feels subdued.
Midrange
At low and moderate volume the midrange is mediocre. How much level you need depends on the source, so my advice is to keep raising it until the mids sound right.
Vocals benefit from the wide, side-to-side spread you get from an earbud, in contrast to the front-to-back depth that silicone-tipped IEMs do better.
Once the level is right, the mids come through open, even and lifelike. Strings have good tone. Post Malone's "Stay" is a good example: the acoustic strumming slices through the mix and blends pleasingly with the singing.
Turning things up cures the hollow, drained quality, but it does nothing for the upper-mid dynamics. Handclaps sound squashed and artificial, closer to harsh bursts than to real claps.
Apart from that, the whole band sounds good. A touch of warmth is missing, but so little that most listeners would never notice. Judging only by what the mids deliver, I would not rule the Traceless out.
Treble
I think the treble is handled very well. Nothing about it is remarkable, yet transients are quick and carry plenty of shine and brightness.
Reach into the top octaves is decent, and a little air is present, just not enough to call the sound airy. The clean, energetic delivery works effectively. Kessoku Band's "Seisyun Complex" shows this, with sharp, lively cymbals and hi-hats.
I would put this range ahead of the other two bands, thanks to good extension and a natural rendering of upper harmonics.
Technicalities
Layering and transient speed are both strong points. The rest of the technical side (stage, imaging, separation, resolution, detail) sits at a middling level without any real faults.
Demanding material such as metal and rock, with lots of guitars and a busy arrangement, is handled well, which suggests the earbuds spend their abilities sensibly.
Genre Synergy
As noted above, metal and rock suit the Traceless. Pop and other modern styles also sound good, but the thin bass takes away some fun unless you are a committed neutral-sound fan.
In general, genre pairing is not a big concern, since whatever you play will come out reasonably.
Conclusion
All things considered, the Traceless is merely decent. It is not the first flathead that springs to mind, since plenty of cheap sets do remarkable work for what they cost.
For someone just beginning an earphone collection, though, I see no harm in starting here. It is a good way to sample many kinds of budget earphones before spending much more. Later, when you evaluate higher-fidelity upgrades, looking back will show how much better they are and make you value superior sound at higher prices.
