Pros
- Extremely cheap
- Decently comfortable
- Clear midrange
Cons
- Feels very cheap
- Narrow, cramped soundstage
- Splashy, annoying treble
- Weak seal and isolation
A $3 earphone that shows where cheap stops being worth it.
TL;DR
Good-sounding earphones keep getting cheaper, with solid options now around $5, but manufacturing still has a floor. The JCally AT1 sits right on it.
It works and is fairly comfortable, but the bass is thin, the treble is harsh, the stage is cramped and the isolation is poor. Once the real cost is counted, a few dollars more buys a much better pair.
Specs
Closed-back in-ear monitor
Single 10mm dynamic driver
Frequency response: 20 - 20,000 Hz
Sensitivity: 103 dB
Impedance: 16 Ohms
What's in the box
JCally AT1 earphones
3 pairs of silicone ear tips (S, M, L)
Where does cheap stop being worth it?
I am always hunting for the best sound per dollar, so one question keeps nagging me: how low can a price go before the product stops being worth owning? Over most of my time in this hobby I put that line at roughly $15 to $20. A pair of Xiaomi Pistons from 2013 cost about $15 and were a minor legend in their day. Today, in 2023, that same money buys far stronger competition and noticeably better sound.
Technology tends to drag quality downward in price, and the proof is easy to find. Models such as the TRN MT1 and the KZ EDX come in around $5, sound surprisingly capable, and carry most of the features that IEMs ten times pricier offered a few years back.
Still, prices cannot fall forever. Materials, labour and physics set a floor under earphone manufacturing, and anything priced beneath it is basically landfill waiting to happen. I think I have found where that floor sits: $3. Meet the JCally AT1.
A Little Background
Many Chinese audio brands are hard to research, but JCally is the opposite. Its website is easy to find and is available in English.
The company, formally Dongguan JieShi Acoustic Technology, is an OEM and ODM whose bread and butter is earphone accessories, things like cables and Type-C to 3.5 mm adapter dongles. Complete earphones are a small part of the catalogue, with only a handful of designs on offer. The AT1 is one of them.
First Impressions
Keep in mind throughout that these are meant to cost $3. That context matters, and I will return to it. It shows right away in the packaging, which is as bare as it gets: a plain box holding two small plastic bags, one for the earphones and one for the tips.
Nothing about the presentation is good, yet complaining about it at this price would be unfair. The tips did worry me, though. While I was swapping sizes, the large pair tore.
Build Quality
A tip splitting during testing made me expect the rest of the AT1 to be flimsy as well.
Nothing actually came apart in my hands, but everything feels cheaply put together. The shells weigh next to nothing, and the cable entry feels as if it would pull free without much of a fight. Straight out of the box there was also a faint plastic odour.
Does any of that really matter? Not much. The earphones worked, and they stayed in one piece for the whole time I used them.
Fit and Comfort
The upside of those featherweight earpieces is that they are reasonably comfortable, and their shape keeps them from slipping out of the ear.
What they fail to do is feel like a proper in-ear fit. Even when pushed into the ear canal, they let a lot of the outside world through. The seal is weak, and isolation is poor as a result.
Sound Quality
By now we know the AT1 looks and feels cheap, which is about what a $3 product should be expected to do. The real question is how it sounds.
I wanted to be pleasantly surprised, but it never happened. In nearly every respect it sounds like a bargain-bin earphone. Here is the detail.
Bass
Cheap earphones tend to fail on bass in one of two ways: either they boom and bloat, or they sound thin and weak. The AT1 belongs to the thin camp.
Whatever I played, anything below about 150 Hz came through with little force. Kan Sano's "Stars In Your Eyes" has a punchy, authoritative kick drum, but on the AT1 it turned hollow and drained of energy.
Midrange
Think of the frequency balance as a seesaw that pivots around 300 Hz, where the lower mids begin. Take weight off the bass side and everything above it rises and takes over the picture.
That is what happens here, so the midrange is the AT1's clearest region.
Clear is not the same as detailed, though. Across my listening the sound felt soft and slightly blurred. On HONNE's "Now I'm Alone", the fine texture in the vocals never emerges the way it does through more capable earphones. I struggle to describe it precisely, but the overall impression is still of something inexpensive.
Treble
The treble goes the same direction, only slightly worse. It is audible enough, but there is little sign of careful tuning, and perhaps none whatsoever.
I suspect the missing bass is part of the problem, since nothing is left to rein in the upper range. The highs splash around, sounding uneven and sharp. M2U's "Body Talk" fares badly: the piercing top-end energy made it tiring to sit through.
Even tracks with a gentle, dark mix suffer, because the detail simply is not there. The shakers in Sam Kim's "Sunny Days, Summer Nights" sound strangely squashed and synthetic, which I found hard to enjoy.
Soundstage
Budget earphones rarely offer much in the way of staging, and even pricier ones are often underwhelming on this front.
Even so, the AT1's lack of space says a lot about how cheap it sounds. In earlier budget IEM reviews I have often pointed out that they still deliver a respectable stereo picture. This one cannot manage even that.
The stage is narrow and hollow, and it is unpleasant to listen to. It shows up on everything, but a good test is a track with a wide, airy mix, such as Madeon's "The City".
Value
Now to the question I opened with. At $3, is the AT1 worth buying?
Definitely not.
I would love to be generous, but it is hardly better than the free earphones that used to be tossed in with other gadgets years ago. Between the feeble bass and the harsh treble, nobody would knowingly spend money on it, even at $3.
It also does not stay at $3. Depending on the seller, it can reach $5 at the time of writing.
Add possible shipping on top and the total creeps into the range where genuinely good earphones start to appear. At that point you might as well buy one of those instead.
Conclusion
Where, then, does cheap tip into too cheap?
Based on this experience, the line is at $3. Good sound has become much cheaper in recent years, yet there is still a limit to how little a product can cost before compromises make it fall short of a complete, working one.
With sloppy treble, a stage that is nearly mono, and thin bass, the AT1 does not reach what I would call good earphone territory.
At its list price it is not useless. It functions, and it does not seem ready to fall apart at the slightest glance. But once the other costs of getting hold of one are counted, its value case disappears.
Cheap earphones have shown that joining this hobby no longer demands serious money. It does demand some money, though, and for now $5 looks like the lowest practical entry point.